Advertisement
Latest News

RBI Seeks Review of Supreme Court Judgment on Rs 8,415 Crore YES Bank AT-1 Bond Write-Off

Advertisement

➡️ Click here to Join Whatsapp News Group - Get instant updates of all Banking News

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has approached the Supreme Court seeking a review of its October 15, 2026 judgment concerning the write-off of ₹8,415 crore worth of Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds issued by YES Bank. The Supreme Court had upheld the Bombay High Court’s decision setting aside the write-off of these bonds, which were permanently written down during YES Bank’s reconstruction in March 2020.

Advertisement

The RBI has now challenged the judgment, arguing that it does not adequately consider the Basel III regulatory framework governing AT-1 bonds and their loss-absorption mechanism. The central issue is whether the bank’s administrator had the legal authority to write off these bonds under the final reconstruction scheme approved by the Government.

YES Bank has also filed a separate review petition challenging the Supreme Court’s judgment. The bank filed its petition on November 13, 2026, while the RBI has also approached the court seeking reconsideration of the decision.

What is the YES Bank AT-1 Bond Controversy?

The controversy relates to the permanent write-off of ₹8,415 crore worth of AT-1 bonds issued by YES Bank in 2016 and 2017. These bonds were written down to zero in March 2020 when the RBI initiated a reconstruction exercise to rescue YES Bank from a serious financial crisis.

Advertisement

The write-off resulted in investors losing their entire investment in these bonds. However, investors challenged the decision, arguing that the write-off was not legally authorised under the final reconstruction scheme.

The dispute eventually reached the Supreme Court, which upheld the Bombay High Court’s decision against the write-off. The judgment has now been challenged by both YES Bank and the RBI.

What are AT-1 Bonds and Why Can They Be Written Off?

Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds are financial instruments issued by banks to raise capital and meet regulatory capital requirements under the Basel III framework. They form part of a bank’s Tier-1 capital and help banks maintain adequate capital to absorb losses and continue their operations during financial difficulties.

Advertisement

Unlike ordinary bonds, AT-1 bonds are perpetual instruments, which means they do not have a fixed maturity date. Banks generally pay interest on these bonds, subject to the applicable terms and conditions.

However, AT-1 bonds carry significantly higher risks than traditional bank deposits and ordinary debt instruments. They are specifically designed to absorb losses when a bank faces serious financial difficulties.

Under the Basel III framework and the terms of the instruments, AT-1 bonds can be permanently written down or converted into equity when specified conditions are triggered. One such condition is the Point of Non-Viability (PONV), under which the relevant regulatory authority determines that a bank has reached, or is approaching, a stage where it cannot remain viable without intervention.

Advertisement

Therefore, investors in AT-1 bonds can lose their entire investment if the applicable loss-absorption conditions are triggered.

In the case of YES Bank, two issuances of AT-1 bonds worth a total of ₹8,415 crore were written off.

Year of issuanceBond amount
December 2016₹3,000 crore
October 2017₹5,415 crore
Total₹8,415 crore

The bonds carried coupon rates of 9.5% and 9%, respectively.

Why Were YES Bank’s AT-1 Bonds Written Off in 2020?

In early 2020, YES Bank was facing a severe financial crisis due to mounting bad loans, corporate governance concerns, deterioration in its financial position and difficulties in raising fresh capital.

The RBI was concerned about the bank’s deteriorating financial condition and the potential impact on depositors and the wider banking system.

On March 5, 2020, the RBI imposed a moratorium on YES Bank and initiated steps to reconstruct the bank under Section 45 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949.

A reconstruction scheme was prepared to revive the bank with the participation of investors led by the State Bank of India (SBI), along with other financial institutions.

As part of the rescue exercise, YES Bank’s AT-1 bonds worth ₹8,415 crore were permanently written down to zero on March 14, 2020. The write-off was intended to absorb losses and support the bank’s capital position.

The decision was based on the loss-absorption provisions applicable to AT-1 instruments. However, investors questioned whether the bank’s administrator had the legal authority to carry out the write-off under the final reconstruction scheme.

What Was the Main Issue Raised by Bondholders?

The main legal dispute was not simply whether AT-1 bonds could be written off. Such bonds are designed to absorb losses under specified regulatory and contractual conditions.

The question was whether the administrator of YES Bank had the necessary legal authority to write off the ₹8,415 crore bonds under the final reconstruction scheme.

An important development took place between the draft and final versions of the reconstruction scheme.

  • March 6, 2020: The RBI released a draft reconstruction scheme that contained a specific provision for writing off YES Bank’s AT-1 bonds.
  • March 13, 2020: The Government notified the final reconstruction scheme, but the specific provision relating to the write-off of AT-1 bonds had been removed.
  • March 14, 2020: Despite the removal of this provision from the final scheme, the administrator permanently wrote off the AT-1 bonds worth ₹8,415 crore.

Bondholders argued that once the specific provision was removed from the final reconstruction scheme, the administrator could not independently write off the bonds.

This became the central legal question in the case.

What Did the Bombay High Court Decide?

The bondholders challenged the write-off before the Bombay High Court through Axis Trustee Services, which represented their interests.

On January 20, 2023, the Bombay High Court set aside the write-off of the ₹8,415 crore AT-1 bonds.

The High Court held that the administrator appointed for YES Bank’s reconstruction did not have the necessary authority to permanently write off the bonds under the final reconstruction scheme.

The court also considered the fact that the specific provision for writing off AT-1 bonds, which appeared in the draft scheme, had been removed from the final scheme notified by the Government.

Following this decision, YES Bank, the RBI and the Union Government challenged the Bombay High Court’s judgment before the Supreme Court.

What Did the Supreme Court Rule?

On October 15, 2026, the Supreme Court upheld the Bombay High Court’s decision and dismissed the appeals filed against it.

The Supreme Court agreed that the administrator could not exercise regulatory powers vested with the RBI and that the write-off was not authorised under the final reconstruction scheme.

The judgment also examined the issue of YES Bank offering AT-1 bonds to individual investors, despite regulatory restrictions concerning the sale of such high-risk instruments to retail investors.

The decision provided legal relief to investors whose bonds had been written off in March 2020. However, it did not mean that AT-1 bonds can never be written off. The judgment primarily concerned the legal authority and procedure followed in the specific YES Bank reconstruction exercise.

Why Has RBI Approached the Supreme Court for Review?

The RBI has now filed a review petition seeking reconsideration of the Supreme Court’s October 15, 2026 judgment.

The regulator has raised concerns about the interpretation of the Basel III framework and the wider implications of the decision for India’s banking system.

The major concerns raised by the RBI include:

1. Basel III Regulatory Framework

The RBI believes that the Supreme Court’s judgment did not adequately consider the Basel III regulatory framework and the provisions governing the loss-absorption capacity of AT-1 bonds.

According to the RBI, these instruments are specifically designed to absorb losses when a bank reaches the prescribed non-viability conditions. The regulator is concerned that the judgment could create uncertainty regarding the enforceability of these provisions.

2. Impact on Future Bank Reconstruction Exercises

The RBI has also expressed concern that the judgment could complicate future bank rescue and reconstruction exercises.

If AT-1 bond write-offs carried out during a bank rescue can be challenged on grounds of procedural authority, investors may become less willing to participate in the reconstruction of financially stressed banks.

3. Protection of Depositors and Banking Stability

The RBI has argued that the 2020 reconstruction exercise helped protect YES Bank’s depositors and restore the bank’s financial position.

The regulator believes that the judgment could have wider implications for the capital structure of banks undergoing reconstruction and the overall stability of the banking system.

4. Loss-Absorption Mechanism of AT-1 Bonds

The RBI’s position is that AT-1 bonds must remain effective loss-absorbing instruments under the Basel III framework. Any uncertainty regarding their write-off mechanism could affect the willingness of investors to subscribe to such instruments and the ability of banks to use them as regulatory capital.

What Does This Mean for AT-1 Bond Investors and YES Bank?

The Supreme Court’s October 15 judgment has provided relief to investors whose AT-1 bonds were written off in 2020. However, the filing of review petitions by the RBI and YES Bank means that the legal dispute is not yet over.

Axis Trustee Services, the bond trustee, has also sought restoration of the bonds and their associated rights. It has initiated contempt proceedings over the alleged failure to implement the court’s judgment.

Importantly, the Supreme Court’s October 15 judgment did not direct an immediate cash repayment of ₹8,415 crore. Restoration of the bonds and determination of the associated financial liabilities are separate matters.

The case also has significant implications for YES Bank’s capital position. The bank has previously indicated that reinstatement of the ₹8,415 crore AT-1 bonds could affect its Common Equity Tier-1 (CET1) capital ratio by approximately 250 basis points, based on its June 2026 position.

The final financial impact will depend on the outcome of the legal proceedings and the accounting and regulatory treatment of the bonds.

Important Developments at a Glance

DateDevelopment
March 5, 2020RBI imposes a moratorium on YES Bank
March 6, 2020Draft reconstruction scheme includes an AT-1 bond write-off provision
March 13, 2020Final reconstruction scheme notified, with the specific write-off provision removed
March 14, 2020YES Bank writes off ₹8,415 crore worth of AT-1 bonds
January 20, 2023Bombay High Court sets aside the write-off
October 15, 2026Supreme Court upholds the Bombay High Court judgment
November 13, 2026YES Bank files a review petition
November 2026RBI approaches the Supreme Court seeking review of the judgment

Also Check This

Advertisement
Advertisement

Hellobanker Team

Hellobanker.in is India's leading banking and finance news portal. Our expert team covers banking policies, RBI updates, financial markets, and investment insights.
Advertisement
News | Jobs | Calculators |
Bank Promotion Course Click Here