Govt Employees can be retired compulsorily in case of Adverse ACR Entries
| ➡️ Click here to Join Whatsapp News Group - Get instant updates of all Banking News |
The Supreme Court of India has clarified that adverse remarks or below-benchmark gradings recorded in a government employee’s Annual Confidential Report (ACR) can be considered while deciding compulsory retirement, even if those entries were never communicated to the employee.
The Court held that compulsory retirement cannot be challenged successfully merely on the ground that the authorities relied upon uncommunicated adverse ACR entries. However, the decision must be based on relevant material, an objective assessment of the employee’s service record and public interest.
The ruling came while dismissing appeals filed by two employees of the Chhattisgarh Government’s Legal Metrology Department.
Background of the Case
The case concerned two Chhattisgarh government employees, Chatur Singh Dhruv and Manharan Lal Sahu, who were initially appointed as Class-IV employees (Peons) in the Legal Metrology Department.
Both employees were subsequently promoted to Assistant Grade-III. Their services were regularised in 2015.
On April 25, 2017, the Chhattisgarh Government issued a circular directing departments to review the service records of government employees who had completed 20 years of qualifying service or attained 50 years of age.
The purpose of this exercise was to identify employees whose continued service was not considered beneficial to public interest.
Following the review, both employees were compulsorily retired on October 9, 2017, under the applicable service rules.
They challenged the decision before the Chhattisgarh High Court, but their petitions were dismissed. They subsequently approached the Supreme Court.
What Did the Employees Argue?
The employees challenged their compulsory retirement on several grounds:
- Uncommunicated adverse ACRs: They argued that adverse remarks and below-benchmark ACR gradings had never been communicated to them and therefore should not have been used against them.
- Non-uniform application of criteria: They claimed that similarly placed employees were retained in service while they were compulsorily retired.
- Entire service record: They argued that the authorities had given excessive importance to recent ACRs instead of properly considering their complete service history.
- Earlier promotions: They contended that their promotions and subsequent regularisation should have reduced the relevance of earlier adverse remarks.
- Punitive action: They argued that compulsory retirement was being used as a substitute for disciplinary proceedings.
What Did the Supreme Court Rule?
A bench comprising Justice Manmohan and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar rejected the employees’ arguments and upheld their compulsory retirement.
The Court relied on its earlier judgment in Baikuntha Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer, Baripada, which established that uncommunicated adverse entries in confidential records can be considered while deciding compulsory retirement.
The Supreme Court clarified that judgments such as Dev Dutt v. Union of India and Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India, which deal with communication of ACR entries in matters relating to promotion and career progression, cannot automatically be applied to compulsory retirement cases.
The Court observed that the mere fact that adverse remarks were not communicated to an employee does not make a compulsory retirement order illegal.
The Court’s important observation:
An order of compulsory retirement is not liable to be quashed by a Court merely on the showing that while passing it, uncommunicated adverse remarks were also taken into consideration.
How Were the Employees’ ACRs Evaluated?
The State Government informed the Supreme Court that a Screening Committee had examined the records of 14 eligible employees, out of whom five were recommended for compulsory retirement.
The committee evaluated their service records using a numerical grading system:
| ACR Grade | Marks |
|---|---|
| A+ | 5 |
| A | 4 |
| B | 3 |
| C | 2 |
| D | 1 |
The prescribed benchmark was Grade B. The two employees failed to meet the required standard based on their overall service assessments.
The Court also noted that their ACRs from 2013 to 2017 showed repeated below-benchmark gradings and concerns regarding their performance.
It clarified that the committee had considered their entire service records and had given additional attention to recent performance. Therefore, the assessment was not based exclusively on a few recent ACR entries.
Does Promotion Remove the Effect of Earlier Adverse ACR Entries?
The Supreme Court also examined whether the employees’ earlier promotions and regularisation had neutralised the adverse entries.
The Court explained that adverse entries recorded before a promotion may lose their significance if the employer grants promotion despite having knowledge of those entries.
However, this principle does not automatically apply to adverse entries recorded after promotion.
In this case, the adverse ACR gradings were recorded after the employees had already joined their promoted posts. Therefore, their promotions and subsequent regularisation did not remove the relevance of those assessments.
Can Government Employees Be Compulsorily Retired Without a Departmental Enquiry?
The Supreme Court reiterated that compulsory retirement in public interest is generally not considered a punishment.
If the competent authority forms its opinion on the basis of relevant material and in accordance with applicable service rules, a departmental enquiry or prior hearing is not necessarily required before passing such an order.
However, compulsory retirement cannot be used as a shortcut to avoid disciplinary proceedings where a regular departmental enquiry is warranted.
The decision must be based on objective material and genuine public interest. It cannot be arbitrary, mala fide or based on irrelevant considerations.
Final Decision of the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court found that the Chhattisgarh Government had followed the prescribed procedure and applied the assessment criteria uniformly.
It found no sufficient grounds to establish arbitrariness, discrimination, mala fides or violation of statutory or constitutional protections.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court upheld the compulsory retirement orders and dismissed both appeals filed by the employees.
Case Details
Official Judgment: Read Supreme Court Judgment (PDF).
Also Read: Punjab National Bank Announces Bonus for Employees for FY 2025-26
Important FAQs
Yes. The Supreme Court has clarified that uncommunicated adverse ACR entries can be considered while deciding compulsory retirement in public interest.
No. Non-communication of adverse ACR entries does not, by itself, make a compulsory retirement order illegal.
Yes. An employee can challenge the order if it is arbitrary, mala fide, based on irrelevant material or violates applicable legal provisions.
Not necessarily. Adverse entries recorded before promotion may lose significance in certain circumstances, but entries recorded after promotion can still be considered.
Generally, no. Compulsory retirement in public interest is not ordinarily treated as a punishment and does not necessarily require a departmental enquiry or prior hearing.
Not automatically. The competent authority must make an objective assessment of the employee’s service record and establish that compulsory retirement is in public interest.
The judgment explains general principles governing compulsory retirement under applicable service rules. Its direct application to Central Government and bank employees will depend on their respective service regulations and retirement provisions.
Please login to comment